Все отчёты
Отчёты Марокко
#59521: "Problem of the scoring when tourist and overflow are closing a second stall in one turn"
notabug: Это не ошибка
1
О чём этот отчёт?
Что произошло? Пожалуйста, выберите из нижеследующего
Правила: правило игры не было соблюдено
Подробное описание
• Какая часть правил не соблюдена в версии БГА
when a stall is closed and a tourist moved to an other stall that with the tourist and the overflow has to be closed, the repartition of point and bonus are good (but check if the players that receive gold or bodyguard receive 1 victory point) except the color of the stall tiles. It put like it's an egality and the active player put a colorless tile and not from the color of the majority player.
A stall is closed when the total is 4 or more. If we have two overflow an 4 worker on a stall, the 4 worker had to be take in account even if there's 2 overflow. So a stall has two overflow and 2 blue worker, one green, one purple. The green and the purple win 1 victory point and either a gold or bodyguard, and the blue win 5 point and can put a tiles of his color.• Видно ли нарушение правил в повторе игры? Если да, то на каком ходу?
It happens in my game #237562685 move #104
Its difficult to see cause in the review of my game there's an other bug that not show when we use cousin. (see log I use cousin but not shown in the review, but this was ok during the game)
• Какой браузер вы используете?
Google Chrome v98
История отчёта
Korton • Разработчики ещё не воспроизвели ошибку:
14 фев 2022 14:20 • it seems to be the same bug that the #56615 noted fixed, but seems to be not really fixed (in this game #230088130 it's move 61-65
In my game 237562685
Its difficult to see cause in the review of my game there's an other bug that not show when we use cousin. (see log I use cousin but not shown in the review, but this was ok during the game)
In my game 237562685
Its difficult to see cause in the review of my game there's an other bug that not show when we use cousin. (see log I use cousin but not shown in the review, but this was ok during the game)
stefano • Это не ошибка:
15 фев 2022 10:24 • Sorry but I don't understand the problem from your description above.
You need to be more clear about:
- Move number
- What do you expect
- What do you see
- Where the problem is.
I suggest you to start a new game, arrive at the point where the problem is, and then open a bug, without making any other move in the game, so I will be able to analyze and understand what's going on.
You need to be more clear about:
- Move number
- What do you expect
- What do you see
- Where the problem is.
I suggest you to start a new game, arrive at the point where the problem is, and then open a bug, without making any other move in the game, so I will be able to analyze and understand what's going on.
Korton • Это не ошибка:
15 фев 2022 11:51 • Ok, i'll try to explain step by step with some screen capture :)
move #105 situation at the beginning
You can focus on :
- L3C3 (lane3, column 3): one green worker, one blue tourist
- L3C4 (Lane 3 column 4): one green worker, one purple worker
pictures: imgur.com/xIyHRdt
Move #106: as you can see in the log I use a Cousin to put a blue worker in L3C3 and in L3C4.
But I don't know why; during the game the blue worker from cousin token was visible in L3C4, but not here when we review the game.
But at this point the position L3C3 is full: one overflow from L3C2, one green worker, one blue worker, one blue tourist
Picture: imgur.com/QUYldC7
Move #107 As the L3C3 is full and I have the majority 2 blue vs 1 green, I (Blue) receive 5victory point and green 2 victory point and one gold and one bodyguard.
We recover our worker, and juice token and I decide to put the overflow of my blue stall toward L3C4
Picture: imgur.com/80olIfc
Move #108 : my blue tourist is from L3C3 and replace by a worker on L3C4.
This position is full: one overflow from L3C3, one green worker, one purple workern and two blue worker (but here, the one from tourist visible, and the one from cousin not visible)
So normally I win this position without uncontested 2 blue vs 1 green vs 1 purple
picture : imgur.com/fB5AmhB
Move #109
As you can see in the log I (blue) won 5 victory point (but it's noted in the text that it's for a tied (egality in french)
Green choose a bodyguard but receive no victory point. But normally he should also receive 1 victory point as he is tied for the third place with green. Green receive nothing (normal cause already 3 gold and it's the maximum and he already had the two bodyguard) but should also receive one victory point.
Except for the victory point missing for green and purple, that seems correct, I'm the only one to get 5 victory point so it prove that it's not a tied for the first place of this position
picture: imgur.com/8486WEA
Move #109 (suite)
After we receive our victory point or bonus we recover our worker.
You can see in the log that purple take back one worker, green take back one worker, and me (blue) take back two worker. This prove that my invisible worker from cousin was there. I repeat during the game no problem to see it.
Picture: imgur.com/DgA6H4x
Move #110 :
With my 2 blue worker versus 1 green and 1 purple, I should win uncontested this place. (Even if there's an overflow, all the worker present in the position should be took in account).
And yes I receive the 5 victory point (me only cause no tied), but I have to put a colorless stall token instead of my blue stall token for the next overflow
Picture: imgur.com/qyCM4EC
I hope the situation is more clear for you.
If you need more information let me know.
Thanks for the developing of this game and your time.
Korton
move #105 situation at the beginning
You can focus on :
- L3C3 (lane3, column 3): one green worker, one blue tourist
- L3C4 (Lane 3 column 4): one green worker, one purple worker
pictures: imgur.com/xIyHRdt
Move #106: as you can see in the log I use a Cousin to put a blue worker in L3C3 and in L3C4.
But I don't know why; during the game the blue worker from cousin token was visible in L3C4, but not here when we review the game.
But at this point the position L3C3 is full: one overflow from L3C2, one green worker, one blue worker, one blue tourist
Picture: imgur.com/QUYldC7
Move #107 As the L3C3 is full and I have the majority 2 blue vs 1 green, I (Blue) receive 5victory point and green 2 victory point and one gold and one bodyguard.
We recover our worker, and juice token and I decide to put the overflow of my blue stall toward L3C4
Picture: imgur.com/80olIfc
Move #108 : my blue tourist is from L3C3 and replace by a worker on L3C4.
This position is full: one overflow from L3C3, one green worker, one purple workern and two blue worker (but here, the one from tourist visible, and the one from cousin not visible)
So normally I win this position without uncontested 2 blue vs 1 green vs 1 purple
picture : imgur.com/fB5AmhB
Move #109
As you can see in the log I (blue) won 5 victory point (but it's noted in the text that it's for a tied (egality in french)
Green choose a bodyguard but receive no victory point. But normally he should also receive 1 victory point as he is tied for the third place with green. Green receive nothing (normal cause already 3 gold and it's the maximum and he already had the two bodyguard) but should also receive one victory point.
Except for the victory point missing for green and purple, that seems correct, I'm the only one to get 5 victory point so it prove that it's not a tied for the first place of this position
picture: imgur.com/8486WEA
Move #109 (suite)
After we receive our victory point or bonus we recover our worker.
You can see in the log that purple take back one worker, green take back one worker, and me (blue) take back two worker. This prove that my invisible worker from cousin was there. I repeat during the game no problem to see it.
Picture: imgur.com/DgA6H4x
Move #110 :
With my 2 blue worker versus 1 green and 1 purple, I should win uncontested this place. (Even if there's an overflow, all the worker present in the position should be took in account).
And yes I receive the 5 victory point (me only cause no tied), but I have to put a colorless stall token instead of my blue stall token for the next overflow
Picture: imgur.com/qyCM4EC
I hope the situation is more clear for you.
If you need more information let me know.
Thanks for the developing of this game and your time.
Korton
stefano • Это не ошибка:
15 фев 2022 12:26 • As I said, I need a new game and you need to pause when the problem happens.
Добавить что-нибудь к этому отчёту
Пожалуйста, укажите всё, что вам кажется значительным для воспроизведения этой ошибки или понимания вашего предложения:
- Другой номер игрового стола / номер хода
- Помогло ли решить проблему нажатие F5?
- Случилась ли проблема несколько раз? Постоянно? От случая к случаю?
- Если у вас есть снимок экрана с этой ошибкой (хорошая привычка), вы можете воспользоваться Imgur.com, чтобы загрузить его и вставить сюда ссылку.